Sarayaku victory..Children of the Jaguar

27 July 2012

Ecuador: Inter-American Court ruling marks key victory for Indigenous Peoples

A regional human rights court has come down in favour of the Sarayaku Indigenous community in the Ecuadorian Amazon in what Amnesty International has called a key victory for Indigenous Peoples.

The Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR) ruling in Sarayaku v. Ecuador, ends a decade-long legal battle by the Sarayaku Indigenous People – backed by their lawyers Mario Melo and the Centre for Justice and International Law (CEJIL)
CGC, partnering with ConocoPhillips, felled forests, destroyed a cultural site, and drilled hundreds of boreholes for seismic surveying on tribal lands despite never gaining permission to do so from the community. As tensions rose, the Ecuadorian government set up military camps on indigenous land.Celebrating from his community, Sarayaku leader José Gualinga said, “the Sarayaku are extremely satisfied with this victory, Sarayaku President José Gualinga speaks before the Inter-American Court.reached thanks to the efforts of our people and the help and solidarity of organizations devoted to the rights of Indigenous Peoples”.Mario Melo, the community’s lawyer, explained that “this favourable ruling for the Sarayaku is the fruit of a large effort on the part of the community’s people, who were key players in every step of the process. For that alone this deserves to be recognized as a milestone in the ongoing struggle of Indigenous Peoples to reclaim their rights”.

The IACHR found that the Ecuadorian state violated the community’s right to be consulted, as well as their community

Children Of The Jaguar
Brilliant Film of Sarayaku struggle. Free download
paste URL
https://adam.amnesty.org/asset-bank/action/viewAsset?id=152613#children

property rights and their cultural identity.

The Costa Rica-based Court also found Ecuador responsible for putting the life and physical integrity of the Sarayaku at grave risk, after the oil company placed more than 1,400 kg of high-grade explosives on the Indigenous People’s territory.

“This sentence will have a far-reaching effect on countries across the region – it makes it crystal clear that states bear a responsibility to carry out special consultation processes before engaging in development projects affecting Indigenous Peoples and their rights,” said Fernanda Doz Costa, Amnesty International’s Researcher on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in the Americas.

“It establishes in detail how consultation should be undertaken: in good faith, through culturally appropriate procedures that are aimed at reaching consent. Thus, exploration or extraction of natural resources cannot be done at the expense of an indigenous community’s means of physical or cultural survival on their own land.”

The IACHR ruling comes at a key moment, when Indigenous Peoples across the Americas are being denied the right to have their voice heard in decisions that often have devastating consequences for their very survival.

Snake tatoos with Wika fruit dye at Sarayaku
Snake tatoos with Wika fruit dye at Sarayaku (Photo credit: heatheronhertravels)

Governments in many countries in the Americas continue to plan and construct motorways, oil pipelines, hydroelectric dams and open-pit mines both within and close to indigenous territories – without obtaining their free, prior and informed consent.

José Gualinga is convinced that the Sarayaku victory will have an impact in the whole region.

“We’ll be watching to ensure the ruling is complied with and that the territories of Indigenous Peoples in Ecuador and across the Americas are respected in the face of damaging extractive activities such as oil exploration. Long live Sarayaku and the Indigenous Peoples of the continent,” he said.

Amnesty International welcomes Ecuador’s acceptance of State responsibility in this case – which it acknowledged last April – and that, according to media reports, the State has already announced that it will comply with the IACHR ruling.

The organization is calling on Ecuador to comply with all IACHR orders – in particular, when it solicits future bids for oil exploration, it must first respect its duty to consult with the Sarayaku and other Indigenous Peoples whose territories could potentially be affected. In addition to taking place in advance, such consultations must be appropriate and in line with relevant international standards, including those established by the IACHR in the Saramaka v. Suriname case in 2007.

“Consultations cannot simply consist in sharing decisions that have been already taken. Instead, Ecuador needs to make a real effort to establish an open and honest dialogue, based on mutual trust and respect and with the aim of reaching a cons

Members of the Confederation of Indigenous Nat...
Members of the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador (CONAIE) march in Quito, Ecuador against the 2002 summit of the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA/ALCA). (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

ensus – this means not imposing anything upon Indigenous Peoples or forging ahead with projects that will substantially affect their rights,” said Doz Costa

“The worrying practice, documented by Amnesty International in a recent report, to use any tool in the box to discourage people from voicing their disapproval of projects that will affect their environment and lands, and to discredit and attack Indigenous leaders, is certainly not conducive to the good faith dialogue ordered by the Court.”

The organization is urging other states in the region to take immediate and decisive action to remedy the situation of hundreds of other Indigenous Peoples who face problems similar to those of the Sarayaku. This should include implementing basic measures to avoid similar human rights violations in the future, including by developing legislation around consultation, training national officials and opening avenues for redress.

Primary school at Sarayaku
Primary school at Sarayaku (Photo credit: heatheronhertravels)

“After this ruling, no country on the continent can deny it has an obligation to carry out an appropriate and participative consultation process with Indigenous Peoples, according to their own cultural practices” said Doz Costa.

A Sarayaku Indian girl in Sarayaku, Ecuador participates in celebrating a July ruling by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR), winning a 2003 lawsuit against oil activity on their ancestral lands in the Ecuadorian Amazon. The IACHR court is part of the human rights protection system of the Organization of American States (OAS). In 1996, Ecuador granted an oil contract to an Argentine oil company which affected 60% of Sarayaku territory without consulting the community who opposed the project. Company activities involved land clearing, placement & detonation of explosives, contamination of the water supply, construction of heliports & camps, threats & violence against members of the community, & complete lack of government environmental control. The Ecuadorian government also set up military camps on the land to protect the oil company operations. The company withdrew from Ecuador in 2011 after vigorous protests. The IACHR ruled the government of Ecuador violated Sarayaku property rights & must pay them $1.4 million dollars in compensation. It also ordered Ecuador to remove buried explosives. Ecuador is the fifth largest oil producer in Latin America & heavily dependent on oil revenue & the ruling comes as Ecuador is looking to lease new oil concessions on indigenous lands. A Sarayaku leader said the ruling sets a precedent protecting ancestral territory from incursion by multinational mining companies in collusion with Ecuadorian oligarchs. (Photo by Dolores Ochoa/AP)
The Sarayaku and Amnesty International have co-produced the upcoming documentary Children of the Jaguar about the community’s fight to defend their rights.

3 thoughts on “Sarayaku victory..Children of the Jaguar”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s