These top predators could do some serious damage to humans but time and again they refrain, even when being tortured to death with their families.
Laura Bridgeman takes a look at the scientific evidence that may explain why dolphins have such a benevolent nature when it comes to interactions with humans……..
Many people are now familiar with the scene that is playing out in the photo to the right. It was taken in Taiji, Japan, a place where hunting and killing dolphins is commonplace. However, this particular photo captures a moment in time that bears closer scrutiny. It presents us with compelling questions about dolphin emotional intelligence and their relationships with humans, and it challenges us to rethink the way we treat these beings of the sea.
Take a closer look at the photo. It captures the last few moments of these dolphin’s lives, as the divers you can see in the water guide them to their deaths. These dolphins are going – unwillingly, yet relatively peacefully – beneath a tarpaulin-covered area where they will be restrained by their tails beside one another.
video of killing here
A metal spike will then be driven slowly into their heads. To watch this process, click here (warning: graphic content is distressing). Their family and friends are thrashing about in the water all around them, utterly exhausted and likely terrified after the hours-long chase that brought them into the fishermen’s nets. If you look closely at the photo, you can see that some of the dolphins are already bleeding, the result of hurling themselves upon the rocks in an attempt to escape the fishermen and the horrors that are occurring beneath the tarpaulin.
The dolphins in this photo have been backed into a corner, with fishermen and certain death on one side, and the net separating them from freedom on the other. What species of wild animal do we know of – or even who among our own – would not lash out when backed into such a corner?
Yet, like the thousands of dolphins before them, these dolphins will not attack. And not for lack of ability – weighing in at around 800 pounds, armed with sharp teeth and powerful tails, these top predators could do some serious damage to those humans in the water. But they refrain, time and again. This undeserved benevolence towards humans is baffling, at best. However, scientific investigations of the dolphin brain appear to offer some insight to this complaisant behavior.
Our brains share many structural similarities with dolphins. For example, we both have a limbic system, which is responsible for handling emotional information. One difference between us, however, is that the dolphins’ limbic system is much larger than ours and, says scientist Denise Herzig, it “may be stretched out over more of the brain,” indicating that “the dolphin brain may have more of a ‘global connection’ to [emotional] information”. This could mean that dolphins are more emotional than humans, and that emotions could figure more prominently throughout their thought processes.
While it might be tempting to think that increased emotions would lead to greater aggression when being backed into a corner, another compelling feature of the dolphin brain appears to account for this notion. Sterling Bunnell, in The Evolution of Cetacean Intelligence points out that the cerebral cortex, responsible for logical thought and reasoning in both humans and dolphins alike, is controlled by the emotional activity of the limbic system. This process is facilitated by what are called ‘neocortical association neurons’.
Bunnell observed that, in human studies, the ratio of these neurons to limbic-system brain stem neurons “is necessary for such qualities as …emotional self-control” and that a decreased ratio is associated with “impulsiveness, emotional instability, irritability, loss of humor”. Bunnell points out that dolphins possess a higher neocortical-limbic ratio than the average human, suggesting that their control over their own emotions is greater than what we experience.
It could be that dolphins, while being more emotional, are more emotionally stable than we are, and are therefore able to better control themselves in stressful situations. This could explain their apparent control over the impulse to lash out at the humans who are so callously ending their lives.
This could also explain why dolphins are so tractable in captivity. Live dolphins are captured in Taiji and are sold to aquariums around the world. Despite being severely traumatized, Bunnell points out that, “captive dolphins… have often shown humor, empathy, and self-control that few of us could match under comparable circumstances”. Indeed. These beings are separated from their families, placed into sterile tanks that are utterly unlike any environment they’re exposed to in the wild, and are forced to perform tricks through food deprivation – if they don’t perform, they don’t eat. Yet they treat nearly every one of their customers with what appears to be kindness and understanding. Something to keep in mind the next time you accept a ‘kiss’ from a captive dolphin.
At this time, we have no way of knowing with certainty that these are the reasons for the dolphin’s perceived benevolence. Some studies suggest that the passive behaviors could result from the incredible stress of the capture and killing process, effectively sending the dolphins into a coma-like state. However, what we do know is that the behavior of dolphins is different than that of other species when placed under extreme duress.
Despite what little we know of a dolphin’s experience of the world, it is difficult to deny that they are highly intelligent and that they are likely capable of significant emotional suffering. We are left with an unsettling yet important question: is it morally justifiable to continue to use and abuse dolphins in the ways we do, whether killing them for food or capturing them to perform for our amusement?
Take another look at the photo, and then process the information contained in this article with your cerebral cortex. Then allow it to percolate through your limbic system. The answer should come to you.
References available on request.
Laura Bridgeman advocates for dolphin, whale, and nonhuman rights. She works for the Earth Island Institute and is a contributor to the Earth Island Journal. She works closely with Ric O’Barry’s Save Japan Dolphins project and is also involved in fostering youth leadership with Earth Island Institute’s New Leaders Initiative.
Follow her @hippiecrite
Operation Infinite Patience
Taiji is a Japanese coastal town that has become infamous for its practice of drive hunting. This deeply unethical activity results in the mass slaughter of thousands of cetaceans. Sea Shepherd ‘Cove Guardians’ report on the latest from the killing shores.
The Cove: dolphin slaughter and toxic meat
It’s the eco-documentary everyone is talking about. Shot in the style of an espionage thriller, The Cove is exposing the secret annual slaughter of 2000 dolphins in Japan. Watch it in UK cinemas from 23rd October
Tsunami stalls Japan’s Dall’s porpoise slaughter, but for how long?
The Japanese tsunami appears to have temporarily halted the annual Dall’s porpoise hunt. Pity the Taiji dolphins haven’t been spared too, says the Environmental Investigation Agency’s Clare Perry
The U.S. Navy has indicated that it intends to disregard the California Coastal Commission’s (CCC) recommendations to mitigate the harmful effects of Navy sonar and offshore training exercises on the state’s marine mammals. In a letter dated July 31, the Navy responded to the CCC’s March objection, which concluded that the Navy’s planned training and testing activities in Southern California would not be consistent with California coastal law.
The Navy’s plans would allow a radical increase in sonar training and underwater detonations off Southern California, beginning in January 2014. While the Navy says it is open to negotiation, it refuses in its letter to abide by any of the state’s recommended mitigation measures, such as avoiding training in globally important foraging habitat for the endangered blue whale…………….. more here: Natural Resources Defense Council
- Dolphin Defenders of Wildlife http://www.defenders.org/dolphin/basic-facts
Save Japan Dolphins savejapandolphins.org/
Fracking could ‘endanger’ dolphin population (itv.com)
Death Penalty for Killing Dolphins? (davidhoganwriter.com)
Dozens of Dying Dolphins Preview Environmental Disasters (guardianlv.com)
Ex-Dolphin Trainer Now Looking Into Mass Die-Off (washington.cbslocal.com)